We finally located the citation for the legend that Holy Cross Church had been struck by lightning just as it was completed and before it had ever been used for worship. References had been made in some of the materials we reviewed for the 125th Anniversary, but no primary sources and very little detail.
Last week while we were reviewing the material for the history wall in the gymatorium, I remarked that it was too bad we never found the original newspaper article...and believe me, I had looked for hours. Susan rechecked the Red Bank Register and came up with this gem from page two of the Red Bank Register, May 12, 1886:
A Church Struck by Lightning
During the heavy thunder storm of last Friday night the new Catholic church on Rumson Bluff, near Seabright, was struck by lightning and badly damaged. The thunderbolt struck the steeple, tearing out one side and throwing several of the steeple ornaments to the ground. The lightning then ran down to the roof, where the slate was torn off of quite a large surface. Some of the timbers were shattered, and other damage was done. The church had just been completed, and John Burke, the builder says that the damage can not be repaired for less than $1,000. The church cost $18,000 to build, and the congregation expected to begin worshipping in the new structure sometime this month.